By and read by Andrea Malmberg
Can a person love solitude and still be lonely?
When a client and partner of UVE’s donated to UVE’s Taking Root Campaign, he answered the question we ask every donor: “What about UVE’s work most resonates with you?” His answer was three words and a wink: “Not being alone ;).”
Those three words kept coming back to me as I thought about what to write for you this month. I laughed when I first read them because the wink is so much like him, and then I sat with them because, with all the talk these days about loneliness, I have a feeling it isn’t the same as being alone. The people we work with are, by and large, people who choose wide open country. Many of them are happiest on a horse at first light with no one else in sight, or walking a pasture where the only conversation is with the grass, the cattle, and the weather coming over the ridge. They treasure their solitude. And also being in good company.
That is the paradox that I want to explore here, because I am living inside it too.
The Anti-Social Century
In February 2025, The Atlantic ran a cover story by Derek Thompson called “The Anti-Social Century.” He argues that the defining social fact of our time is aloneness, much of it chosen. Americans spend far more of their lives by themselves than they did a generation ago, at home, with screens, with food that arrives at the door. The car moved many of us out to the suburbs, the television privatized our leisure, and the smartphone finished the job.
What hit me most is that many of us say we feel fine. In an interview about the piece, Thompson described people as “choosing to be alone.” I get this, as I see the toll forced togetherness takes on many multi-generational ranch families who have created a familial and ranch-hand “neighborhood” with expectations galore.
Yet, I can also see that the cost of choosing to be alone shows up quietly, in what he calls the middle ring of our relationships: the neighbors and acquaintances, the people down the road who think differently than we do and whom we used to see at the feed store, the church supper, the school board meeting. When that ring thins, he argues, we lose practice at disagreement, we lose our capacity to build community, and we grow more vulnerable to a politics of us versus them. Abbey’s “Watch Your Othering: How to not Pit Agriculture Against Agriculture” from five years ago is a worthy read or reread!
I recognize that middle ring. Rural people have always depended on it. It is the client-turned-friend who shows up with his pickup when your truck breaks down, carrying a too-heavy load of fats as you crawl up the banks of the Columbia River. This middle ring has been thinning in agricultural communities for a long time, long before smartphones or a pandemic.
Where This Began for Me
In 2013, I completed my capstone for the Master of Applied Positive Psychology at the University of Pennsylvania. I called it Flourishing Pastoralists: Managing for Well-Being while Restoring the Grasslands of the World. The premise was straightforward, and I still believe it: the health of the grasslands depends on the well-being of the people who steward them. If we want land that is regenerating, we need land managers who are flourishing.
Even then, the research pointed to isolation. Farmers once had better mental health than the average working population, and that advantage appeared to be slipping. Researchers pointed to mechanization, financial strain, and social isolation. Fewer hands on the land means fewer people beside you.
From the positive psychology literature, I drew seven domains of human flourishing: prevalent emotions, satisfying life, vitality, personal resources, self-actualization, supportive relationships, and trust and belonging. I deliberately kept the last two separate. Supportive relationships are our close ties—the people we can call at midnight. Trust and belonging reach further. As I wrote then, people often “have the ability to have close friends and family ties but do not innately or have not built the capacity to interact with members of their community or with strangers in meaningful ways.” A rancher can have a strong marriage and grown children who call every Sunday, yet still feel like a stranger at the county meeting. One question I chose for that domain is as old-fashioned as it is revealing: “Most people can be trusted, or you can’t be too careful?” Another asks how much you agree that “I feel close to the people in my local area.”
Because of the scholars I was fortunate to learn from at UPenn (whose current work I am highlighting here), I created a way for people to measure the middle ring twelve years before The Atlantic gave it a name.
Honoring the Love of Solitude
Here I want to honor the people we work with. For many land stewards, solitude is a source of vitality—the very thing that restores them.
Adam Grant, the organizational psychologist at Wharton and one of my professors at UPenn, has helped me think about this. Early in the pandemic, he wrote a piece for The New York Times called “Yes, Even Introverts Can Be Lonely Right Now.” He assumed being an introvert made him immune to loneliness, until he found himself deeply isolated in his first year of graduate school. He writes that “being introverted has nothing to do with liking alone time.” The desire for solitude comes from a separate trait, which psychologists call independence. Loving solitude and being lonely can live in the same person on the same day.
That is a relief to me. The cowgirl who loves riding out by herself at first light is healthy just as she is. If she feels lonely, she can keep her morning rides and also make time for the people who matter to her so she doesn’t feel alone.
In a New York Times essay this fall, “The Scientific Case for Being Less in Touch With Your Friends,” adapted from his new book Vibe, Grant goes further: “the frequency of interaction does not determine the quality of a relationship.” He points to data suggesting that most people can spend up to 75 percent of their time alone without feeling lonely. Some of my happiest days go without seeing anyone, but my dogs and the cattle and I’m perfectly content.
Yet, that is never enough for me. Grant also notes that the most creative teams alternate between quiet stretches and surges of intense communication. That is the ebb and flow UVE’s remote crew and clients find ourselves in. I know, and I think what was expressed by our client in his brief note is that in our pursuits we are not alone.
The land knows that rhythm well. Herds graze. Plants rest and recover. Graze, rest, recover, graze again. Grant writes, “Distance enables us to reconcile, rejuvenate and reinvent.”
Trust Built by Showing Up
Grant’s work on trust speaks to rural life too. In Vibe, he describes astronauts who learned to trust crewmates they didn't particularly like because trust grew from reliability and shared stakes.
That matters enormously in rural communities, where your neighbor may hold different politics, a different faith, or even a different fence-line philosophy, and you still share the watershed, the weather, and the fire season. In my capstone, I wrote that “for trust to be durable, it needs to be justified,” meaning trust grows out of our actual experience of one another. We belong by showing up, and by continuing to show up, until our experience of each other gives trust something to stand on.
Belonging can also be built smaller and faster than we imagine. On his WorkLife podcast, Grant spoke with Jane Dutton, another one of our MAPP professors, who studies high-quality connections. Her research finds that “forty seconds of interaction, a positive, caring interaction, has measurable impacts on both people.” Forty seconds. A wave from the truck. A real question at the sale barn. A phone call to a neighbor you have not seen since branding.
In his Times essay, Grant names one of those small rituals: pebbling. Some penguins court a mate by presenting a smooth, shiny stone suitable for building a nest together. The human version is sending someone a link, a photo, or a short note because it made you think of them. “Each pebble is a bid for connection,” he writes. I love this image for our community. A photo of a pasture recovering after rest, sent to the neighbor who taught you to read it. A rainfall total texted to a friend two counties over. Small stones, carried a long way, that say I’m thinking of you.
The research he cites on reaching out moves me most. When people drafted messages to reconnect with old friends, fewer than a third sent them, because they assumed they would be unwelcome. In 90 percent of cases, people who did reconnect found it fun, and a voice on the phone strengthened the tie more than a text. Short, periodic notes of care sent to patients after a hospital stay for mental health challenges cut their suicide risk by as much as half. Small, sporadic touch points matter more than we think.
Situated: The People and Places That Bring Out Our Best
Angela Duckworth—yes, another professor at UPenn—has a new book that speaks right to this. In Grit, she showed that passion and perseverance matter. In Situated: Find the People and Places That Bring Out Your Best (2026), she writes that “grit, while necessary, is sometimes not sufficient.” The people we keep close, the mentors we choose, and the places we live and work shape who we are able to become. Her advice: “It is far, far better to make your situation better first.”
That landed for me. For years, I have watched land managers try to tough it out in isolation, as if loneliness were a character weakness to be overcome by working harder. Duckworth offers a gentler, and I think truer, frame. To flourish, we change our situation. We put ourselves near the people and places that bring out our best, and we become those people and that place for someone else.
This is Holistic Management thinking in another key. We manage the whole. A person is situated in a whole too: a landscape, a family, a community, a network. When that whole is healthy, each part has a better chance of thriving. It takes effort, as Duckworth puts it, to “make your situation your ally,” and that effort pays off.
My Own Intellectual Loneliness
Since Tony's passing, I have experienced a kind of loneliness I did not anticipate. I have family, friends, colleagues, and a community who care deeply about each other. What I lost was my thinking partner of 27 years. Tony was the person I argued ideas with over breakfast and, passionately and uncomfortably at times for others, in classes we guided together or over dinner with friends. We would push back on a half-formed thought until it either fell apart or became something. I have come to call what I feel intellectual loneliness.
For a while I waited for that to resolve itself. It did not. So I have had to take responsibility for my wantings. In Holistic Management, there is no room for shame or blame. We manage for what we want. Our Holistic Context names the quality of life we are reaching for, and we test our decisions toward it. I realized I had written "stimulating relationships and lifelong learning" into my life and then left them to chance. If I am intellectually lonely, the next step is mine to take.
So I have been reviving relationships. Calling people I had let drift. Asking for the long conversation. Being the one who reaches out first—which, for someone who often prefers her own company and her own pace, does not come easily. These are my pebbles. Grant's research gives me courage here. As he puts it, "strong attachments can exist without regular interaction." The door is usually still open.
Gillian Welch has a song called “Only One and Only.”
There's a hundred bluebirds
Up above the clouds
Putting all the color in the sky
And twice as many teardrops
There to wash it down
Every one's another lullaby
But there's only one and only
Who could go and leave me lonely
I have been listening to it a lot this year. There is a way of being the only one that is a kind of fidelity, a deep solitude that is also a deep love. There is also a way of being the only one that means sitting alone with your thoughts, waiting for someone to answer back. I have known both. I think most of the people we work with have known both.
And then someone answers back. People like our client who left a little note with his donation have made it so I am not alone —and definitely not intellectually lonely. His three words were a pebble too.
Managing for Belonging
This is why we built the LifeEnergy.Guide. It grew directly out of the Flourishing Pastoralists work, and it is intended to help people enhance their well-being one decision at a time. It asks short questions based on the science of Positive Psychology across the seven domains, including supportive relationships and trust and belonging, so you can see where you are flourishing and where you are running thin. Then it helps you build a values-based action plan.
It honors your solitude. It helps you notice whether your solitude is still restoring you, or whether it has quietly become a habit of keeping to yourself. It treats your well-being the way a good grazing plan treats the land: something you monitor over time, something you can influence, something you manage for.
[Link: https://www.uvehub.com/lifeenergyguide]
Taking Root: Why UVE Exists
So what is UVE’s work, if one of the people who knows it best can sum it up as “not being alone”?
Our client with his short note said it better than any mission statement could. UVE exists so that we may support each other, so that we are not alone. We gather people who love the open spaces and often love finding solitude in them, and we give them a place to share the responsibility of the land they steward, their decisions, and their questions. Our Hub, our guiding, our monitoring, and the Savory Global Network behind us form a middle ring. A place in which trust is built through shared work and justified by lived experience. A place to come back to water. In Duckworth’s language, UVE is a situation that brings out our best.
That is the heart of our Taking Root campaign, Growing a Stronger Foundation for Regeneration. When we talk about roots, we usually mean the grass: deeper roots, more water held in the soil, more resilience when the drought comes. Roots also hold a community together. Every gift to Taking Root deepens both. It keeps the land stewards we serve among people who know their work, share their questions, and will still be there next season.
Our client found what resonated with him in three words. If those words strike a chord with you too, I invite you to help UVE take root.
[Donate to Taking Root: https://www.zeffy.com/en-US/donation-form/uve-taking-root-growing-a-stronger-foundation-for-regeneration]
I would love to hear from you.
Where in your life does solitude restore you, and where has it slipped into isolation? Who is in your middle ring, and when did you last spend forty seconds with them? Who could use a pebble from you this week? What are you wanting that you have left to chance?
Thank you to our client for the wink and the reminder. Let’s keep “not being alone,” together.
Sources and further reading
Thompson, D. (2025, February). The anti-social century. The Atlantic.https://www.theatlantic.com/magazine/archive/2025/02/american-loneliness-personality-politics/681091/
Mosley, T. (2025, January 29). The trouble with donating our dopamine to our phones, not our friends [Interview with Derek Thompson]. Fresh Air, NPR. https://www.wlrn.org/npr-breaking-news/2025-01-29/the-trouble-with-donating-our-dopamine-to-our-phones-not-our-friends
Malmberg, A. (2013). Flourishing pastoralists: Managing for well-being while restoring the grasslands of the world [Master’s capstone, University of Pennsylvania].
Grant, A. (2020, April). Yes, even introverts can be lonely right now. The New York Times. Reprinted by the Association for Psychological Science: https://www.psychologicalscience.org/news/yes-even-introverts-can-be-lonely-right-now.html
Grant, A. (2026, September 30). The scientific case for being less in touch with your friends [Adapted from Vibe]. The New York Times. https://www.nytimes.com/2026/09/30/opinion/friendship-frequency-interaction.html
Grant, A. (2026). Vibe: The secrets of strong connections in a lonely world. Viking. https://adamgrant.net/book/vibe/
Grant, A. (host). We don’t have to fight loneliness alone [with Jane Dutton]. WorkLife with Adam Grant, TED. https://www.ted.com/podcasts/worklife
Duckworth, A. (2026). Situated: Find the people and places that bring out your best. Scribner.
Welch, G. “Only One and Only.”

